What did bellatrix lestrange do to hermione in the deathly. I had to cut a lot of gushing out and remind myself what this post is actually about analyzing how well the film version carried out. Rowling became so popular, that they were in turn made into a film series. Part 1, released in november 2010 and warner bros, as with every other installment, chose to put their own spin on certain aspects of the story. The second half of dh part 2 was a total disappointment. But i did see harry potter and the deathly hallows on saturday. The depth of the scene is completely lost,so is that of remus and tonks all seen dead in the end, just like that. In harry potter and the deathly hallows, we get a whirlwind revisitation of all the places harry might call home, and finally end up at the only real place thats ever been a real home to him, hogwarts.
They arrive to capture harry and the others because of the taboo. Harry potter and the deathly hallows that was not in the book. In the movie harry kept the secret of hunting horcruxes to himself, ron and hermione as per dumbledores explicit instructions. After the book was devoured i bingewatched the two films it was turned into. The first track, obliviate, provides a feeling of heavy sadness. Whether because they split the final book in half or its just one of the easiest to translate to the screen, harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 is the movie most loyal to the book its. They did that with every book when it was made into a movie, though. Harry potter and the deathly hallows harry potter wiki fandom. Differences between harry potter and the deathly hallows. This post is a comparison of major plot points in the movie and book versions of harry potter and the deathly hallows pt. I dont love all the changes, and im not trying to record all of them here there are plenty of big differences between the book and the movie that. Harry potter and the deathly hallows ending book vs movie harry potter has no idea how famous he is. Rowlings 2007 novel of the same name and features an ensemble cast. Book vs film spoiler alert please only read this if you have read the book and know the plot or dont mind being told it.
Why was the ending of the book different from the ending. In the book, hermione learns quickly how to be a better. Where was brave neville, proclaiming his loyalty to dumbledore and condescendingly telling voldy that he would join hi. Whats the difference between harry potter and the deathly hallows the book and harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 the movie. How harry potter characters should have looked by the book.
Deathly hallows part 1, has become more extravagant, all thanks to alexander desplat and his official movie soundtrack for this film. List of differences between the harry potter books and films. What were some disappointing differences between harry potter. Part ii 2011, harry potter and the sorcerers stone 2001, finding dory 2016, harry potter and the goblet of fire 2005, harry potter and the order of the phoenix 2007. In the book, dudleys gang of friends is not with him when harry confronts dudley, they had left to go home. The battle scene in the book is so much better than the movie and at the end of the book harry does use the elder wand at least once he doesnt just break it in half like it shows in the movie. Harry potter and the deathly hallows analysis shmoop. My answer includes a lot of speculation on the specific decisions of the movie makers, but i have studied booktofilm adaptation. It is the second of two cinematic parts based on j. The deathly hallows and the book vs book 1426 words bartleby. I have seen the movies a few times and i just wanted to share my opinion on hermiones torture scene.
Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 wikipedia. Harry potter and the deathly hallows follows the formula that rowling uses for all of the harry potter books and that many authors of book series use in order to maintain their brand identity all seven of the titles in the series are harry potter and the blah blah blah. The whole harry vs voldemort final battle was utterly disappointing. Sep 30, 2019 the second half of dh part 2 was a total disappointment. The way albus dumbledore is described in the books versus how hes. Why was the ending of the book different from the ending of the. Nov 01, 2016 the dom begins the beginning of the end and looks to see how well harry potter and the dealthly hallows part 1 stuck to its half book. Harry potter and the deathly hallows was released in hardcover on 21 july 2007 and in paperback in the united kingdom on 10 july 2008 and the united states on 7 july 2009. The ultimate harry potter question and answer book with over 4000 questions on harry potter and the deathly hallows. This book is divided into two sections beginning with dip your toe in that has 10 over all questions about each chapter. The movie that i waited years to watch became a torture to sit through.
Harry potter and the deathly hallows to be split into. Ollivander appears to be familiar with the deathly hallows, while in the book, he doesnt understand what the term means. Harry potter and lord voldemort duel from harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 2011 longtime harry potter director david yates understood the weight of the franchises final showdown and stuck with his instincts to. Part 2, we never ever find out about remus lupins son teddy. Alas, when the potter movies got the movie treatment, adhering to the novels. The deathly hallows and the book vs book 1426 words. Jul, 2011 harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2. Book details that 100% shouldve made it into the movie or tv. What follows is a list of the eight harry potter and the deathly hallows. The journey is hard, filled with events both tragic and triumphant, the battlefield littered with the bodies of the dearest and despised, but the final chapter is as brilliant and blinding as a phoenixs flame, and fans and skeptics. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 wikipedia.
Harry potter and the deathly hallows themes shmoop. Etsy is the home to thousands of handmade, vintage, and oneofakind products and gifts related to your search. The crimes of grindelwald 2018, harry potter and the deathly hallows. In soho, new york, there was a release party for the american paperback edition, with many games and activities. When i was 11, i read harry potter and the sorcerers stone for the first time. In the movie, it is hermione who comes across the name in a book she picked up for. My answer includes a lot of speculation on the specific decisions of the movie makers, but i have studied book tofilm adaptation. While the book explains why they didnt hand the want over because the goblins were told lestrange lost her wand recently.
The second to the last film of the famous movie and book franchise, the harry potter series. Aug 25, 2015 adaptation, book vs movie, daniel radcliff, emma watson, harry potter, j. It was in the deathly hallows, when dudley seems genuinely worried. List of differences between the harry potter books and films harry. Part ii 2011 popular comparisons with first movie click to add. Harry potter and the deathly hallows, chapter 36, the flaw in the plan. Parents need to know that harry potter and the deathly hallows is a grim, violent fantasy book. The best moviebook to contrast is the first movie of the deathly hallows and the book, mainly because it has the greatest similarities between the book and the movies. Whats the difference between harry potter and the deathly hallows the book and harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 the movie. In the movie, instead of watching him get killed in action, we see his family mourning over his body in the great hall. I had to cut a lot of gushing out and remind myself what this post is actually about analyzing how well the film version carried out the story of the book.
Why was the ending of the book different from the ending of. Lets be honest here, deathly hallows as a book tried to cram too much into a single work. Rowling, 97814088557, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. While the book explains why they didnt hand the want over because the goblins were told lestrange lost her wand recently so if granger revealed her possession of the wand their mission would have failed, the movie doesnt i understand its hard to convey this factor because it was in harrys. Why was the ending of the book different from the ending of the movie in regards to the elder wand. Comparing harry potter and the deathly hallows, part 2, the book and the movie. Deathly hallows is my second favorite book in the series, and it is currently my favorite movie of the series. The horcruxes and the deathly hallows july 23, 2007 by john 30 comments no surprises here every one of the horcruxes was either mentioned by dumbledore in prince the locket, the cup, and nagini or listed by many in fandom as very likely horcrux possibilities the ravenclaw tiara and harry himself. The film, which is the eighth and final instalment in the harry potter series, was written by steve kloves and produced by david heyman, david barron, and rowling. Secret of the tomb 2014, miss peregrines home for peculiar children 2016, fantastic beasts and where to find them 2016, fantastic beasts. Read on to find out what i think about harrys final adventure. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 is a 2010 fantasy film directed by david yates and distributed by warner bros. A spectacular finish to a phenomenal series, harry potter and the deathly hallows is a bittersweet read for fans.
Movie post in sooo long, but its probably because i havent seen that many movies that have been based on books that ive read. Harry potter and the deathly hallows book vs the movie. I was watching the film harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 in which harry broke the elder wand. The great hall scene in the movie where snape threatens any student or. Harry potter and the deathly hallows to be split into two. So we now take a look at 10 things they changed for the movie from the book. The best movie book to contrast is the first movie of the deathly hallows and the book, mainly because it has the greatest similarities between the book and the movies.
Why does one chapter in deathly hallows change many peoples perspective about snape. Rowling asks us to consider what makes a home so homey, and why the idea of home deserves to be defended at. Movies harry potter and the deathly hallows to be split into two movies. What were some disappointing differences between harry. Book details that 100% shouldve made it into the movie or. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1, lost in. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 1 this is long, just so you know. The films are nowhere like the books by some important, or less, information in the books that the directors thought was not needed till later. Harry potter and lord voldemort duel from harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 2011 longtime harry potter director david yates understood the weight of the franchises final showdown and stuck with his instincts to deliver an emotionally satisfying resolution. In the book bill weasley tells harry why goblins dont trust wizards. Harry potter and the deathly hallows book depository. Tying up loose ends at time made for a tedious read, so while i miss some portions of the book, im not crying about it. Another difference from the book is in harrys time in the notquitedeath limbo space with dumbledore. The bluray edition of philosophers stone includes commentary from director chris columbus that reveals that the final scene of the film where harry, hermione and ron depart on the hogwarts express was the first scene shot.
Harry potter and the deathly hallows, book vs movie part 1 and 2. Harry potter and the deathly hallows, book vs movie part 1. List of differences between the harry potter books and. Harry potter and the deathly hallows nov 23, 2010 i havent done a book vs. I was the same age as harry when he first received his hogwarts letter. Dumbledore uses his deluminator 5 times in the film however in the book he clicks it. In the movie fenir greyback is the leader of the snatchers. Harry potter and the deathly hallows part 2 is a 2011 fantasy film directed by david yates and distributed by warner bros. Characters show wonderful qualities such as bravery, loyalty, perseverance, and sacrifice, but deaths still occur in nearly every chapter major as well as minor.
Below are a list of changes made to the stories of the harry potter books when they were adapted into feature films. There are spoilers of major scenes, events and deaths. Hi, i am currently rereading harry potter and the deathly hallows for the first time since it has come out. Rowlings harry potter saga marks the epic conclusion of the story of a boy who goes through the halls of a private school for wizards and witches and his quest to figuring out how to defeat the most evil wizard in history. Splitting the movie into two parts worked because there was so much to cover in order to stay true to the book and live up to the fans expectations. Part 2 scenes that were totally different in the book, and made me pick my jaw up off the floor. Ollivander doesnt admire voldemort like he does in the book. The possible reason why the movie has the least amount of major differences is because, it was split into two parts which allowed it to remain more loyal to the original text. Thats because hes being raised by his miserable aunt and uncle who are terrified harry will learn that hes really a wizard, just as his parents were. Harry, ron and hermine are almost at the end of their journey. Harry potter and the deathly hallows changed a lot in being adapted from the book to the films.
682 1275 1057 722 599 1339 695 420 761 37 801 1127 27 1072 628 1016 911 500 1120 779 868 695 505 1463 654 716 772 539 1167 1353 1277 1412 415 1280 154 897 286 959 649 124 1410 1332 577 47 192 942 279 1181